Wednesday, August 17, 2011

One Of The Best Comedy Shows EVER!

For those of us of a certain age it was: YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS, a 90 minute (!) live  
comedy/variety show which aired on CBS for four seasons, 1950 - 1954.

The show starred Sid Caesar, Imogene Coca, Carl Reiner and Howard Morris + guest stars. Every week these four accomplished lunatics would perform in hilarious skits and routines which, if you weren't careful, would have you rolling on the floor with laughter. I mean, we would laugh until we cried. I can't remember how many times I actually fell off the sofa laughing, but there were plenty. I was a kid then, but even I knew I was in the presence of genius.

Some of the skits are available on YouTube on rickety looking tapes - too bad that the show's producers didn't have the foresight to film the show, the way Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz would film I LOVE LUCY beginning in 1951. Oh well, no use crying over spilled milk.

Never thought I'd see myself writing this but - thank goodness for YouTube. Ha! (Though there's really not a whole lot of the show to see online.)

Some of my favorite SHOW OF SHOW skits were the ones in which the cast pretended to be speaking or singing foreign languages but were actually spouting gibberish instead. I know, I know, in today's politically correct world that sounds horrific, but thankfully, back then, we didn't know any better. We laughed in our innocence because it was very funny.

The cast actually sounded as if they were speaking Italian, or French, or Hungarian or whatever. And they always looked as if they were just having the best time. Caesar, especially, who'd grown up in a Jewish neighborhood with different European accents flowing in and out of the restaurant where he waited tables as a kid, was an expert mimic. The rest of the loony cast followed suit.

They sometimes did parodies of opera in full costume which I always looked forward to. They did THE MIKADO, romantic operettas, grand tragedies - nothing was sacred to them - in the original languages, except not. I have never seen anything funnier. Here's the thing: they did it all perfectly seriously, they were not mocking the originals, they were performing them - more or less. It was this nonsense that first introduced me to opera. Somehow, I became intrigued and went on to discover one of the great musical joys of my life.

Many years later I managed to call in and speak with Sid Caesar on the old Phil Donahue Show - before Oprah - and told Sid how much his work meant to me and how his old opera skits had turned me on to real opera. He was a bit surprised by that. It was a thrill to talk to him, let me tell you.

Dream team, Mel Brooks and Neil Simon (among others) wrote for YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS. Woody Allen and Larry Gelbart wrote for Sid's later shows, though they are usually all (mistakenly) lumped together as one writing staff. But still, think about it - Mel Brooks, Neil Simon, Woody Allen and Larry Gelbart all wrote for Sid Casear.  It seems incredible.

The sheer brilliance of the show was this: NOTHING was beyond, Sid or Imogene or Carl or Howie. They would and could do ANYTHING. They would throw themselves into each skit as if it were all that mattered. If something went awry, they ad libbed. In fact, much of what went on was ad libbed. When something worked extra well, they went with it. They were fearless. My feeling has always been that all four must have been prodigiously intelligent and it was just the luck of the draw that brought them all together at a set place and time in history. For our benefit, of course.

Imogene Coca (1908 - 2001) was the good natured foil of many a skit. She had a kind of odd frailness about her that somehow drew you in. She appeared innocently snared in the general craziness while at the same time enjoying the heck out of the thing.

 Occasionally she was called upon to play a floozy (usually with fish net stockings), she threw herself into the part and was always hilarious. Her allure was mystifying, but it was there. Somehow she held her own with the rest of that incredible cast, three of the biggest ego-centric hambones ever created.

Sid Caesar (1922 - ) - the more obviously driven of the four (and I always suspected, the shyest) - was always the leader in whatever havoc they were causing that week. He was the one in control - the glue that held the thing together even when calamity threatened. Where he went, the others followed. They could not have picked a better head honcho. Next to Imogene Coca, I believe he was the most fearless of the bunch.

Back then Carl Reiner (1922 - ) seemed to me to be a guy born to play second banana and conscious of the fact though perhaps not altogether happy with it. However, he gave everything he had to the show each week He was superb in whatever he did - mostly because he would do the craziest things and always look as if it were all perfectly normal. That was his gift.

Howard Morris (1919 - 2005) was a born character actor, born to play third banana and didn't seem to mind it a bit. He was perfectly happy stealing scenes from the other three (which he did often). Of the four, he appeared to enjoy the audience laughter most.

For those of you too young to have seen YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS in situ, I almost feel sorry for you. Hell, I do feel sorry for you. You missed out on one of the great television shows of all time.

To read about Sid Caesar (still alive and kicking at 88), his life, career and early television work, please check out his pretty comprehensive Wikipedia page.

To watch a Show of Shows skit, From Here to Obscurity, go here.

To watch another classic skit, The Clock, please go here.

As an added bonus: Don't forget to catch Peter O'Toole in the classic comedy film MY FAVORITE YEAR based on the last year of YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS, 1954. Here's the trailer.


  1. I believe your assessment of the cast to be on the money. It was indeed a fortuitous fate that brought them together and gave those laughs to us.

  2. CW: Sometimes fate plays the good guy. :)

    I loved this show and have the best memories of it. I also liked the show they did later with Nanette Fabray, though I always missed Imogene.

  3. Do I remember? I sat with my mom and we laughed till we cried.
    Imogine was a ballerina and they had her on a rope flying across the stage. The shows were fabulous.
    Remember the Texaco show?
    I think Nanette Fabray had a hearing problem. She was another
    Brillant talent. She was in a movie
    an did a highchair number dressed like a baby. Stuck with me forever.


  4. This show was tops, and nobody could touch those four crazies and their terrific team of writers for creativity and comic inventiveness.

  5. Yes, I loved that show as did my family. I would race upstairs from visiting neighboring kids to see it.

    But now that I read the write-up, I realize I missed some. Drat! I have to try to catch up somehow.

    All I remember is that if I saw Sid Caesar doing doubletalk or if I see it now, I fall over laughing. Or see the skit of him acting like a general, and he was a doorperson getting ready for work. Hilarious.

    I have the PBS comedy writers show which included Carl Reiner and Larry Gelbart and a lot of other hilarious people. I fell over laughing watching that.

    I wonder how many younger comedians go back and watch what they can of those four geniuses.

    And I liked Nanette Fabray who could be very funny, too, but I missed Imogene, who was a one-of-a-kind person.

  6. Yvonne: That Nanette Fabray movie was THE BAND WAGON with Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse, Jack Buchanan and Oscar Levant. Levant played her husband.

    I wish I could see that ballerina skit again. Imogene was the tops!

  7. Jacqueline: You said it! When I name top ten TV shows, this is definitely one of them.

  8. Kathy: Yes, I liked Nanette very much. But I always missed Imogene. Still that show was funny too.

    But YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS was an unique event. Remember the giant meatball skit?

  9. Wonderful memories, Yvette! My dad loved TV and this was one of his favorite shows along with the Honeymooners and Phil Silvers and Milton Burl...oh gosh..I could go on and!

  10. Pat: Oh we watched THE HONEYMOONERS and Phil Silvers and Uncle Miltie too! All great shows.

    But nobody could match YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS.

    Phil Silvers used to make me laugh so hard though. What a great show that was.

    When Milton Berle dressed in drag, it was such a scream!

  11. Speaking of YouTube, somewhere on there you can find a long 1997 interview with Sid Ceasar, divided into parts. Excerpts can be found on this edited version:

  12. Darn! I missed some of these skits, I think. I don't know some of them.

    Will have to play detective and see what I can find. I can't believe that I missed some skits.

    My family watched Sgt. Bilko, my father loved that show.

    And, I watched Phil Donahue, too, and still miss him being on tv. He is a good guy and his show was, too.

  13. Woody Allen is often credited as a writer for Your Show of Shows...but that's a misnomer. (He did write for Sid Caesar's 1963 variety show and I believe one of Caesar's comedy specials, so people have a tendency to lump the two together.) Larry Gelbart wasn't on the Show of Shows writing staff, either -- he worked on Sid's follow-up, Caesar's Hour. (Larry has stated in interviews, however, that he's flattered when they make him a member of the Shows writing staff.)

    In 1973, some of the classic sketches from the series were culled to make a feature film entitled Ten from Your Show of Shows--and why this hasn't been made available on home video is one of the true mysteries in the entertainment business. Some of the most timeless comedy you'll ever see, including the classic "This is Your Life" sketch which still makes me hurt with laughter every time I watch it.

  14. Mark: Thanks for the link. I'll look for the interview. THese people were/are national treasures as far as I'm concerned.

  15. Kathy: I loved Bilko!

    I never did understand why there wasn't room on TV for both Oprah and Phil.

    He had a great show.

  16. Ivan: I stand corrected. :) I'll adjust my post.

    Ten From Your Show of Shows. Jeez.
    I'd LOVE to see that.

  17. Phil Donahue's show was cancelled because of his political stances. He was very anti-war and had on like-minded guests at the start of the Iraq war.

    Here is a piece from FAIR(Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting) which explains this:

  18. Thanks for the link, Kathy. This would not surprise me.


Your comment will appear after I take a look.