Friday, May 25, 2012

Horse-A-Thon: THE BLACK STALLION (1979) starring Kelly Reno, Terri Garr and Mickey Rooney

The gorgeous film poster.

This is my entry in the first film Horse-A-Thon (first I ever heard of, anyway) hosted by Page over at her blog, MY LOVE OF OLD HOLLYWOOD. Many movie mavens will be contributing over the next three days to this unique blog-a-thon, so please check in and see what other terrific 'horse movies' other participating bloggers will be lovingly showcasing.

Going in, I admit that my post today is nothing less than an unabashed fan letter. I am a total Black Stallion fan-girl.


THE BLACK STALLION (1979), directed by Carroll Ballard from a script by Melissa Mathison, Jeanne Rosenberg and William D. Wittliff, is based on the popular books by Walter Farley. Transferred to the screen, the production was blessed to have the talents of cinematographer Caleb Deschanel who turns the entire film into a visual work of art. It was doubly blessed to have a perfectly realized and unobtrusive musical score by Carmine Coppola.

When I think of THE BLACK STALLION, the only word that comes to mind is 'exquisite'. It is truly an exquisite film from the rather stark opening scenes until the final credits. I've seen the movie many times and I still cry at the end while the credits roll - no sadness or tragedy, just the allure and effect of overwhelming beauty which is almost too much to bear.

The plot:

It is 1946. A young boy named Alec Ramsey (played naturally and effectively by Kelly Reno) and his father are traveling by ship off the coast of North Africa. It appears to be a freighter more than a luxury passenger liner. There are moody, dramatic, slightly disorienting shots of the ship moving along the gray, roiling water -  just enough to set the lonely atmospherics. The ship is all white, gray and black, the railings and floors of the passageways, gleaming dark wood. We know almost immediately, from these first few camera shots that we're in for something special.

From what I understand,  Deschanel used natural light as much as possible while filming. That accounts for the romantic realism (I suppose you'd call it) which heightens events and paradoxically makes the horse appear to be more a creature of myth than reality.

The father is never named and we only see him in a few scenes. We learn that he is probably a gambler by trade - this from his crafty play at a high stakes poker game, where, surrounded by several ominous characters of various colorful nationalities, he triumphs.

Played by a wonderfully sagacious Hoyt Axton (who I understand was known more for his country/western singing than his acting) - it's a small jewel of a performance and Axton should have been nominated along with Mickey Rooney. But as usual, I'm getting ahead of myself.

Once back in their cabin, father checks his winnings and picks out a small metal figure of a horse which he gives to Alec. He tells the boy the story of Alexander the Great and his magical horse, Bucephalus. The boy is not totally taken in by his dad's fanciful story, but he holds on to his little treasure. Clearly father and son dote on each other.

There is a black horse being transported on the ship (with a ruthless minder, a sinister Arab, ready with a whip and a sneer) who has taken the boy's interest. In fact Alec sneaks little sugar cubes to the animal and places them in a row on the open port-hole ledge. We get a close-up of the horse's muzzle as he sniffs then gobbles each sugar cube daintily. But the Arab shows up and chases the boy away, then grabs the remaining sugar cube for himself. We hear the horse's outraged noises.

Sometime during that night there is a fire in the ship's hold and an explosion rocks the ship. These harrowing scenes are cut quickly, shot from assorted angles giving the impression of chaotic movement as the fire grows, the ship lists, takes on water and begins to sink - no music, just the awful noises of frenzied desperation and the ship's horn ineffectually sounding.

Panicked passengers and crew grab whatever life jackets they can. The horse manages to break free and still harnessed and trailing retaining ropes, jumps a railing into the water. Father and son are separated and the boy, crazed with fear, tumbles head long into the water as well.

In the black, hellish night of sinking ship, oil-slick water, fire and screaming boy, we see the horse frantically trying to stay afloat - his head and neck being pulled sideways - ropes tangled in the ship's propeller.

Alec has held onto a small army knife. He dives underwater and frees the horse, saving the animal's life as well as his own, for the horse then swims furiously away, the boy hanging on for dear life.

A critic at the time, I think maybe, Pauline Kael (not sure) said that the first half of this movie was  breathtaking fantasy or fairy tale and photographed in just that way. The second half is more down to earth and the photography, art direction and story take on a much different tone. I agree with this assessment.

The boy (Kelly Reno) realizes he still has the little metal horse his father gave him.
Alec washes up on an idyllically beautiful island. Dazed and exhausted, he realizes he must now fend for himself. While looking around for the horse, he hears cries of distress and comes across the stallion lying in the sand, trapped, his remaining harness and ropes entangled among the rocks. The horse avoids death a second time because of the boy who inches in warily and cuts him loose. Finally the entire harness pulls free and clearly exuberant, the horse runs off.

Later in some of the most idealistically beautiful photography I've ever seen, they are reunited and Alec must work hard to earn the horse's full trust. The boy is canny and smart beyond his years and eventually figures out a very clever way to ride the horse, first approaching him while both are in the water. During this entire process, boy and horse form a mythic bond.

Some of the more glorious camera shots are from overhead - breathtaking scenes at twilight, shadowy and sepia toned, other times stark black, gold and red/orange. You will never see a horse more exquisitely or elegantly photographed.

Three scenes I remember best: one of the horse, earlier, standing alone on a cliff high above the water almost in silhouette, looking every bit the wild master of his domain. Then there's a remarkable close-up later (in natural fading light) of part of the horse's head blending into the night, his eye fluttering closed in almost complete darkness as he falls asleep. The boy nestled next to him.

A third moment of movie magic occurs as the boy puts the small metal horse given him by his father on top of a boulder. The camera closes in and we see the small stationary figure of myth up close, while in the far distance, we see the black stallion running along the edge of the coastline. On the soundtrack a theme which evokes all things Arabic - or at least, the Arabia of the imagination - a theme which becomes the horse's own as the movie progresses. A dazzling sequence.

Now most of the scenes on the island are, necessarily done in silence accompanied only by occasional soundtrack and natural background noises. So, except for the few scenes on the boat, the first half of the movie is almost dialogue free which only adds to its mystique.

There is no voice-over, no boy talking to himself or to the horse, no sentimentality or cutesy stuff. There is just scene after scene of haunting beauty. Horse and boy joyous in their companionship.

Of course it cannot last.

Alec and the horse are eventually rescued and reality resumes in the second half of the movie. Gone is the island. Back home in an industrial type town outlined in dark, menacing factories, Alec must find a way to keep his horse. The differences between this existence with all its inherent boundaries and limitations and the freedom of the island could not be more pronounced than in the scene of the nervous horse absurdly surrounded by a white picket fence.

Alec's mother (Terri Garr) is thrilled that her boy has been found safe, but uneasy and confused about the horse in her back yard. One morning 'The Black (as he is now called) runs off when he is frightened by the garbage men, making for one of the more frantic, heart-pounding sequences in the second half of the film.

As The Black flees, Alec chases after him. The horse now races through an unfriendly, unfamiliar, obstacle-laden landscape risking encounters with automobiles and startled humans, disrupting the ordinary day to day life of a busy town. The camera work is brilliant as we follow The Black on this bleak journey. The bright colors of the island have given way to dull brown, black and smokey gray.

Eventually, by several strokes of good fortune, the horse will be safely stabled at a small farm outside of town owned by Henry Dailey, a washed up old jockey - played by Mickey Rooney.
The last section of the film is made up of the intense training and preparation for an improbable three-way race between The Black and two thoroughbred champions. An event which the bitter Henry Dailey hopes will make up for his past failures.

The race, when it comes, is nail-bitingly thrilling as The Black (ridden by Alec) must come from behind to win. There is no music to accompany the mesmerizing camera work, just the horses' loud, rapid breathing and the pounding of their hooves. I remember sitting in the theater spellbound, caught up in the visuals, transported.

In the end, when the credits roll, there is a new musical theme (not heard during the film) as more scenes between Alec and The Black on the island are unveiled in slow motion. I am usually moved to tears.

To classify this brilliant film as just another children's movie is to do it an injustice.


The outrage for me is that not only did Caleb Deschanel NOT win an Academy Award for his absolutely incredible cinematography, he wasn't even nominated. That's when I began to realize that most award givers are clueless when it comes to art. The hell with 'em.

Here's a link to the original trailer with an overwrought voice-over which you should ignore. This is what happens when money people get hold of art and trample all over it to make sure that the audience isn't too stupid to understand what they're seeing.

And finally, a link to the theme played during the end credits.


  1. A lovely fan letter to a beautifully photographed movie. I remember the boat sinking scenes as particularly horrifying. I agree the cinematography is quite magical at times.

  2. Dear Yvette - Now it's my turn to recommend a movie to you — "Buck."

    I posted about it here:

    It's a very moving documentary, and you'll be blown away by it!


  3. Yvette,
    Your love of The Black Stallion shines through. Well, it actually lights up the sky like a beacon! For that I'm thrilled. There is nothing better than reading an article when the writer has such deep feelings for the subject.

    Exquisite it the perfect word to describe this film. Thanks for providing so many beautiful snapshots for anyone who hasn't been fortunate enough to see it.

    I've often said that there are a few films that really have to be seen on the big screen in order to fully appreciate the cinematography. I've said that about Last of the Mohicans, Gorillas In the Mist and of course Titanic. You're so very lucky to have been able to see The Black Stallion as it should be seen for the first time.

    It's heartwarming that so many are writing about horse films because they have such fond memories, the film is so special to them.

    Thank you for sharing your experience with us and for writing such a joyous, heartfelt love letter on a great film.

    If anyone hasn't seen The Black Stallion I'm sure they'll add it to their 'must see' list after reading this.

  4. Great post! I have to admit, I've always preferred the book to the movie. But the island scenes, and later the race scenes, are so stunningly beautiful that I can't help enjoying them for their own sake.

  5. "The Black Stallion" is one of the movies that my special needs son adores. He is a boy who really enjoys classic animation with its frenetic action and I find his choice of this quieter form of story telling intriguing. He will play back the scene of Reno and Rooney on the porch ("Do you think The Black can run?") with a look of deep satisfaction. A true work of art that reaches so many different types of people.

    Wonderful article, Yvette.

  6. Wonderful choice!

    Although I am generally not a Mickey Rooney fan (he grates on my nerves for some reason like Nicholas Cage) I loved this movie!

    Thansk for your compliments on my daughter's wedding. She and her fiance picked out the venue and we fell in love with it. It was a beautiful day ;)

  7. Jacqueline, the sinking of the boat is as horrifying to me as the sinking of of ships in other movies like TITANIC or THE POSEIDON ADVENTURE. Though in THE BLACK STALLION it is, necessarily, of shorter duration. But it's grip on the emotions is just as strong. At least for me.

    So well done.

  8. Mark, I must tell you - I have BUCK on my Netflix queue and have just been waiting for the right moment to watch it. :)

  9. Page: You're most welcome and thanks so much! I was afraid I was going overboard (ha!) but then I thought, nope, this how I really feel about the movie.

    It is one of my favorites - made my top ten, actually. (I'm working on a 100 Best Movies List as we speak.)

    I agree with you about viewing this on a big screen if at all possible. Yes, there are certain movies that should be seen in a theater for the first time. I'd add MASTER AND COMMANDER with Russell Crowe to that list. A few others come to mind, but I think I'll save that for another post.

    Thanks for thinking up this Blogathon - it was great fun to participate.

  10. Elisabeth, I've never read the book so I have no comparison to make. But since I am a very visually oriented person, I would still probably prefer the aesthetics of the film. Caleb Deschanel is an artist. And oh, that soundtrack. Perfection.

  11. Yes, there's something in this film for everyone, Caftan Woman. All you have to do is pay attention. Your son gets it.

  12. Yes, even Mickey Rooney couldn't ruin this. I was never a big fan though I did like him well enough in the very early Andy Hardy films with Judy Garland. He was so energetic. :)

    I think he's still around. Must be about a hundred by now. Good for him.

  13. Yvette - I am in total agreement! This film is totally gorgeous and the Black Stallion is the Cary Grant of the horse set. Your post is beautiful and a fitting tribute to a stunning film.

  14. Great, detailed post, Yvette! I haven't seen THE BLACK STALLION in many years (and then, only on video, which is a crime, considering how beautifully-filmed it is...if ever a film cried out for a Blu-Ray release, it's this one) and you brought the story vividly back to life.

    At the time, I remember preferring the first half of the film, as I'm a sucker for Crusoe-type stories. Your post makes me want to check it out again soon!

  15. You're right - this is an exquisite film. The cinematography is amazing. I'm glad you reviewed this movie.

  16. This is a beautiful story and the cinematography is absolutely beautiful. The score fits perfectly with the scenes. Also, the shipwreck scene, is one that you will not soon forget. Great review for a great film!!

  17. Yvette, an excellent review of a film I have enjoyed watching several times over the years. I have been holding on to the CD. It's one of the most innocent films I have seen, if that makes sense. I wish the film was centered entirely around the little boy and the great black with no other elements in it except for the sand and sea. The sequel, THE RETURN OF THE BLACK STALLION, also based on Farley's book I think, didn't work as well for me. Never touch a classic.

  18. Yvette, I can't think of a better choice for Page's Horseathon than Caleb Deschanel's film version of THE BLACK STALLION! Although it's another film I haven't seen in a very long time, your loving, lyrical descriptions of the boy and "The Black" really brought back the feeling of really getting into this modern classic. Like you, I'm mystified as to why THE BLACK STALLION didn't get a truckload of Oscars. Why is it that so many such films all too often take years to be recognized as a timeless classic? Well, at least people can appreciate it now, and I guess that's the most important thing! BRAVA on a beautiful post, my talented friend!

  19. Thanks, FlickChick! I'm pleased to learn that there are other movie mavens out there who appreciate this unique film the way I do. One of the reasons I like blogging so much - 'meeting' like-minded people. :)

  20. Thanks, Jeff! This is certainly a film to be viewed often. Magic of this sort shouldn't be forgotten.

    As you know I enjoyed your post on BITE THE BULLET very much. Thanks for dropping by.

  21. Thanks, Silver Screenings! I really did enjoy writing about it and I guess it showed. :)

  22. Thanks so much, Dawn! This was certainly a labor of love for me. :)

    I loved the cinematography and the score by Carmine Coppola was superbly handled.

  23. Prashant:
    Yes, I know how you fell but -
    the boy had to go home eventually, you know. They couldn't have stayed in paradise forever.

    The sequel was very disappointing. They didn't have the talents of Caleb Deschanel's camera genius and you can instantly see the difference. The sequel is just a horse movie.

  24. Thank you so much, Dorian. I am still miffed over the Oscar thing even though I know it's not as important as the recognition and love we movie mavens have for this beautiful classic.

    As I said, this was very much a labor of love. :)

  25. Wonderful post! I have never seen this, but it looks like a beautiful movie. It is rare that a director lets a movie go for long periods with no dialogue, but if the scenes/actors are good enough, you dont need it. I will add this to my watch list!

  26. Lovet his movie, but haven't seen it since I was a wee lad. I think I need to get a hold of it soon and show Aidan.

  27. Perfect Number 6: Thanks! It definitely is one of the more beautiful movies ever made. No hyperbole. See it. :)

  28. Oh, for sure, Ryan. If he's old enough to appreciate the aesthetics, he's old enough to see it. :)

  29. This is one of those rare times when I love the movie as fully and completely as I love the book. Are they carbon copies of each other? Not at all. But they both fire the imagination. The only other horse movie that comes close for me is "Seabiscuit."

  30. We probably don't need to go into why I have so much difficulty with this movie (ask Cliff Alperti about my "Mickey Rooney is my Kryptonite" problem some time) but this is a first-rate review, Yvette. I remember when this first came out and the cinematography was so beautiful that I begged my mom to let me (and my sisters) go see it. I came away with an experience that...well, I thought Teri Garr was good.

  31. Agreed, Cathy. I also enjoyed HIDALGO and I'm surprised no one picked it to talk about for the Horse-A-Thon.

  32. Ivan, I do think this is a girl/woman and grown man movie. Let's leave it at that. Ha!

    Mickey is not a fave but he didn't ruin the movie for me.

    P.S. You are simply awful. :)


  33. Wonderful post! This movie is so beautiful, and it's a testament to the fact that "children's films" can be done as art and appeal to all ages. As a horse-crazy kid, I grew up reading all the Black Stallion books, and the movie really captured the amazing and exquisite creature he was in those stories.

  34. angelnumber25: Thanks for dropping by. Yes, we're in agreement. It IS possible to create art which children and adults can both enjoy and appreciate in different ways.

    I never did read the books, but I was kind of horse crazy myself as a kid though I grew up in Manhattan.

    I only got to ride a bit in my teen years when I took the ferry to Staten Island where there was a stable full of nice horses. Though one did run away with me....!

  35. I'm glad so many other people share my love of this gorgeous movie. You can still watch it today and not know it was made in 1979, it's so classically filmed and scored. Thank you.

  36. Love this movie and completely agree with your assessment of it. Beautifully written and described. Well done you.


Your comment will appear after I take a look.