Sunday, December 18, 2016

5 Favorite Christmas Movies

I do this list every year and every year it's the same movies since I haven't really seen anything new that captures my imagination or makes me feel especially Christmasy. Though I may be in the minority, I dislike Lifetime TV Christmas movies with their lachrymose plots and past-their-prime actors attempting to breathe life into plots force fed with pretend holiday cheer. I'd rather watch A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS over and over again - the original one. Or Raymond Briggs' THE SNOWMAN, a wistfully beautiful animated short film.

For this short list, I've left off the more obvious classics like A CHRISTMAS CAROL since it's a given we all love those. I am especially fond of three versions: the Alistair Sim one, the George C. Scott one and the Patrick Stewart one. I used to be fond of the musical, SCROOGE, but now, not so much.

We all need an extra bit of Christmas cheer these days so hopefully one or two of my favorite movies will do the trick. Escapism is the key word for the next four years, beginning with now.



1) THE THIN MAN (1934) Though some of you might think that W.S. Van Dyke's classic movie based on Dashiell Hammett's rather dark book is NOT exactly Christmasy, I say, think again. Not only does the story take place over the Christmas holidays, but William Powell and Myrna Loy as the zany sophisticates Nick and Nora Charles share oodles of snappy dialogue and sparkling bon-mots, drink martinis, throw a party, open presents, and tackle a murder plot full of nitwits and thugs. A very young and beautiful Maureen O'Sullivan is also in the cast, as is a bad-tempered gigolo played by a young and sulky Cesar Romero.


2) LADY ON A TRAIN (1945) Deanna Durbin (directed by Charles David whom she later married) plays a flighty heiress who spots a murder from her train window as her train shuffles into Manhattan on Christmas eve. And we're off and running. Durbin gets a mystery writer involved in her hunt for a killer because who else would one go to for help in solving a crime than a mystery writer? What is it about Christmas and murder? Only in movies like these where it's all improbable fun and absurd villainy and Durbin gets to sing a very nice version of Silent Night, over the phone to her dad in California. And Dan Duryea and Ralph Bellamy play sleazy, sinister guys up to no good.


3) THE MAN WHO CAME TO DINNER (1942) Based on a stage play by George S. Kaufman and photographed more or less like one (but not to its detriment), this film does not concern us with murder but merely with a bad-tempered but powerful radio personality of immense popularity played by the irascible Monte Woolley. He is the sort of man who, if this WERE a murder a mystery, would be bumped off in the first ten minutes. But anyway, here he just takes a nasty fall on the snowy doorstep of a conservative mid-western family and is forced by medical exigency to spend Christmas with the sort of people his over-bearing New York personality loathes. Bette Davis plays his long-suffering secretary, Anne Sheridan plays a gold-digging Hollywood glamour gal, Jimmy Durante plays a maniacal old pal and the wickedly charming Reginald Gardiner plays a Noel Coward type and almost steals the movie.


4) CHRISTMAS IN CONNECTICUT (1945) A delightful film starring Barbara Stanwyck as a hyper-drive, domestically hapless NYC magazine columnist/editor doing her best to play happy housewife (with borrowed baby) for her boss, publisher Sidney Greenstreet (who is quite wonderful), while falling in love with a soldier (Dennis Morgan) on holiday leave. The plot is kind of clunky, but since this all takes place in a movie-style Connecticut farm house during a movie-style white Christmas with jingly sled and horses, it's all good.


5) MARCH OF THE WOODEN SOLDIERS aka Babes in Toyland (1934) Christmas wouldn't be Christmas without this old chestnut. The truth is, my un-reasoning affection for this movie knows no bounds. Watched it as a kid every year growing up: WPIX, Channel 11.  I even like to sing along with the Victor Herbert songs. The scene is Toyland, toyland, beautiful girl and boy land - and the incomparable Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy play Santa's helpers. Though the duo often does more harm than help, for instance turning Santa's order of 100 six inch soldiers into 100 six foot wooden marching soldiers. It's just as well though, for when hordes of shaggy, snarling bogie men attack Toyland, the soldiers come in handy. I love the old fashioned characterization of nursery rhyme characters such as Little Bo Peep and Tom the Piper's Son and The Old Lady Who Lived in a Shoe (literally) and Mother Goose, etc. SO much fun - even the odious Victorian villain Barnaby who overreacts his way into acting infamy. Ha!


16 comments:

  1. I haven't seen The Thin Man or The Man Who Came To Dinner for a long time, and I'd forgotten there were Christmas themes. They are now in my queue. I own Christmas in Connecticut and love it. A couple of my most faves are Love, Actually and The Holiday.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad I reminded you, Nan. :) LOVE, ACTUALLY is a good one, I love Hugh Grant in it. But I'm always saddened by the Alan Rickman/Emma Thompson story line. I don't seem to be familiar with THE HOLIDAY. I'll look it up.

      Delete
    2. I wrote about it here: http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2009/12/holiday.html

      Delete
  2. Yvette, did you review "Christmas in Connecticut" in the past? I know I read a review and then watched the film and liked it too. It's one of very few Barbara Stanwyck movies I have seen. As for Laurel & Hardy, what can I say — they're such great fun and so full of innocence. They're on top of our list of favourite comedians. The one thing I don't lend is our collection of L&H CDs. Well, actually two — I don't lend my comic-books either!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wouldn't lend my CDs either, Prashant. :) I did review CHRISTMAS IN CONNECTICUT, yes. I've reviewed all these movies in the past. But since they are my favorites I'll just keep on reminding everyone at Christmas time. I try to refresh the language every year. :)

      Delete
  3. I am also very fond of The Thin Man and The Man Who Came to Dinner. I have said before that I should watch Lady on a Train but I still have not done that. And I don't know why I haven't ever tried Christmas in Connecticut either. Sounds just like my kind of movie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you'd enjoy them very much, Tracy. They're both silly, but in a good way. Well, nothing is sillier than MARCH OF THE WOODEN SOLDIERS and yet, I couldn't do without it. HA! LADY ON A TRAIN is SO much fun. It's the only Deanna Durbin movie I think I've ever seen or for that matter, ever want to see. :)

      Delete
  4. Stan and Ollie and Victor Herbert are always part of my Christmas viewing. I love The Man Who Came to Dinner because it made my daughter a Grant Mitchell fan!

    The 1951 version of A Christmas Carol has been our Christmas Eve tradition for as long as I can remember. A couple of years ago when I gave the Robert Zemeckis/Jim Carrey version a try despite my dislike of stop motion. I caught a scene while channel surfing and was intrigued. Surprisingly, it is now my second favourite version of the story.

    This year I have introduced my daughter to three off-the-beaten-track Christmas movies to joy, tears and success: Kathy O' (1958), The Holly and the Ivy (1952) and Three Godfathers (1936). We are well on our way to adding new traditions to the old.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, THREE GODFATHERS - yes! The other two I'm not familiar with. I'm afraid we must differ on Jim Carrey - I cannot tolerate him. He gives me the icks. Ha!
      What would Christmas be with the bogeymen? :)

      Delete
    2. Here's a little write-up on KATHY O' which is currently up on YouTube if you are interested. It is not a movie that will take up your whole day.

      http://www.caftanwoman.com/2016/12/merry-christmas-kathy-o-1958-jack-shers.html

      Delete
  5. we love Powell and Loy in anything; and March of the Wooden Soldiers also... must get the others - tx for the recommendation...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're very welcome, Mudpuddle. If you get a chance to see them, I hope you'll like them as much as we do.

      Delete
  6. I've seen all except the Laurel and Hardy movie. And I've seen them often. I have to add "The Christmas Story," with the little boys, one who wants a bb gun.
    In fact, my neighbor's 6-year-old answered my question of "what do you want for Christmas," by answering, "a bb gun and a trampoline." I replied that as the movie says, "a bb gun can poke your eye out," and a trampoline is too big for an apartment.
    I'll try to find a few of these classics.
    How are the grandchildren? Are they waiting for Santa to arrive?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kathy: "BB Gun" was a tv production several years ago, after a short work by Jean Shepherd; i seem to have misplaced the book, but anything by him is really funny...

      Delete
  7. The folks at Turner Classic movies must agree with you about 'The Thin Man' being a Christmas movie. They are showing it on December 23 -- followed by the other four of the Powell / Loy series.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great minds think alike. :) I hadn't always thought of THE THIN MAN as a Christmas movie until a few years ago. Then I saw the light.

      Delete

Your comment will appear after I take a look.