Friday, April 7, 2017

Friday Forgotten (or Overlooked) Book: HARE SITTING UP (1959) by Michael Innes



"You yourself, don't you find it a beautiful clean thought, a world empty of people, just uninterrupted grass, and a hare sitting up?" (Women in Love by D.H. Lawrence)

I didn't actually promise I wouldn't write another review of an Innes book ever again, so here we are. As most of you know I am a MAJOR Michael Innes fan so I can't reasonably be expected to stay mum about one of my favorite authors for long. I've written enthusiastically about his books over the past eight years of my blogging existence, so if you're interested, just use the search thing at the bottom of the page. It's finally working again.

HARE SITTING UP reads like a story in which Innes (pseudonym for John Innes MacIntosh Stewart - 1906 - 1994) was having fun seeing how far he could go with a 'thriller mystery' without actually killing anyone off. In fact, near the end when a killing does occur, it's not a very prepossessing one or for that matter, of much real importance. What is most fun about this book - at least for me - is the journey. That is often the case with several of Michael Innes' books - my favorites, in fact.

Here Innes indulges the very intriguing and popular trope of identical twins who are adept at taking each other's places and have done so since childhood. This is revealed to us early enough so it's not meant as a real surprise. We do, however, get misdirection and a long discussion between passengers on a train, only small parts of which have any relevance to anything which happens later. Most of it is glib conversation about how the world might end and might not dreary society as a whole be ready for that end (don't forget that this was 1959 - the Cold War was in full swing and scientists were discovering all sorts of various and sundry ways to end it all.)

"I'm much more interested," Gavin said at once, 'in something else. It's the twilight of the gods idea - the fascination of bringing everything else down with you as you fall. Hitler was gripped by that, I imagine. But you needn't necessarily be a Wagnerite to feel the tug of it."

Alice crossed a green leg over a yellow one. "Death-wish stuff," she said. "How does it correlate with actually dying? Does anybody know? You see, we've talking about the dangers of concentrating power - and far more potential destructive power than has ever existed before - in the hands of old, sick men..."

And on it goes, in Innes, we have discussions of this sort which might mean something as we go along but then again, might not. In HARE SITTING UP, the discussion is just to put us in a frame of mind for the pile of absurdities which come next. The train passengers themselves - except for two - will not show up again in the story.

As for the twin thing, well here we have two brothers: Miles Juniper and Howard Juniper - one is a scientist, a germ warfare expert (uh-oh) and the other is a public ('public' in the English sense) school headmaster. And remembering how much Michael Innes loves the preposterous, he has one of the men disappear - but which one? He also has Chief Superintendent Appleby show up at the school in disguise to interview the brother - just in case spies should be lurking - that sort of thing.

Some people (with little or no imagination) do not like Michael Innes' sense of absurdity and his oft indulged propensity for outrageous plots and odd humors. But I'm not one of those people. In many ways, I sometimes think that Innes was one of the early proponents of 'magical realism' except we didn't call it that back in the day. His use of coincidence and Appleby's nearly clairvoyant knack for putting two and two together with various leaps of intuitive logic, are legendary.

The plot of HARE SITTING UP is a tangled one as Appleby goes off on wild goose chases and even recruits his wife (improbably he's done this a couple of times before) to check out a school once he realizes that something might be amiss there. She jumps right into the thing by improvising a wild game (Judith Appleby comes from a long line of eccentrics, see APPLEBY'S END for the definite proof) in which she and several students run all over the campus looking for clues of something or other.

In the meantime, Appleby confronts a wacky member of the aristocracy, a reclusive ornithologist living at a remote estate with a whole profusion of birds and ducks who amble in and out of the house at will. Also in residence, a granddaughter to keep an eye on him.

Eventually, Appleby begins to get the hang of the thing and shows up at a secret, rainswept government installation on a remote Scottish island. The atmospherics here are particularly effective.

From there, it's back to the birds and the loony lord who may or may not be plotting a crazed something.

It's all improbable and not meant (despite the subject matter) to be taken too seriously. As I mentioned, it's the journey that I enjoy most with Innes and the often obtuse use of language and literary allusions - the knack for which is unlike any other genre writer. Yes, he was often pulling our leg or even, perhaps, making sneery faces, but I always got the idea that he was doing it in a very indulgent way - like an uncle who knows he's smarter and wittier and more literary than anyone else, but manages somehow not to make you resent him.

Yeah, I guess you can call me a Michael Innes fan-girl.

Since this is Friday, don't forget to check in at Edgar Award nominated author Patricia Abbott's blog, Pattinase, to see what other forgotten or overlooked books other writers are talking about today.

29 comments:

  1. Me too...I am also a Michael Innes fan-girl...I read most of his books when I was younger. Thanks for the review and reminder, maybe I will read a few again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I reread certain Innes favorites all the time. :)

      Delete
  2. Sounds like a great read, Yvette! I'll look for it. I've only read one Innes book but have several on the shelf, although not this one☹️

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not all his books are equal - but some are more equal than others. In other words, I hope you pick up one that will encourage you to read more of him. You just never know. I think possibly Innes requires a certain mood. :)

      Delete
  3. Your love of Michael Innes has affected me. In the past month, I've found a handful of Innes paperbacks in thrift stores. Before reading your reviews, I may have passed them up. But now, I buy every Innes book I run across! Now, to find time to read them!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good for you, George! I've been buying them from Abe Books online for a while now - really inexpensive and free shipping. Can't beat that. But I'd rather have bought them in a used book store or thrift shop. Alas, nothing close by where I live now.

      Delete
  4. Pull my finger, sweetie, go ahead hee hee hee. Not heard of Michael Innes, but...after this, how can I not head immediately for the hare hole?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! As you please, Mathew. I recommend Michael Innes to anyone who enjoys language and its various uses, not to mention. literary bon mots by the dozen.
      Innes is unique.

      Delete
  5. Though I'd read a couple of other Innes titles and enjoyed them way back when, a few years ago I read 70 pages of a paperback edition of HARE SITTING UP and yours truly gave up. Given the story's urgent premise (do tales like THE SATAN BUG ring a bell?), the novel's approach seemed much too casual and, ultimately, tedious. Another Innes novel, APPLEBY AND HONEYBATH, has languished on my shelves for years, so if I eventually get to it, I can only hope it'll be more satisfying--and that I'll get all the way through it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Barry, I can see how you might go astray with HARE. I recommend THE CASE OF THE JOURNEYING BOY, THE SECRET VANGUARD, OPERATION PAX or maybe THE MAN FROM THE SEA. (The last one is not an Appleby book.)

      Delete
  6. MI is my go-to author; i fell in love with his books early on and i don't think i've found any writer i like better... for civilized wit and humor he just can't be beat..."Hare" is one of his best...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm with you, Muddy. (If I may call you that.) :) He really is unique. No one wrote quite like him or concocted such outlandish plots in the name of 'thriller'. And I don't even mind that half the time I don't know or get the literary allusions because eventually I figure it out or if I'm stumped enough, I go look it up. Innes makes me think - not a bad thing.

      Delete
  7. So, is this book funny? When I read about the wacky aristocratic ornithologist, I started laughing. Is the whole book like this?

    I say this because while I'm glued to MSNBC, the scene in D.C. just gets grimmer and grimmer. Now we have to deal with Gorsuch, a Bannon pick, who wants to roll back every gain and right about 80 years, even more.

    I hope everyone is prepared with signs, phone numbers, emails to be constantly protesting. And it's a lifetime appointment. And some of the best justices are quite elderly. They're alert and smart, but still. ...

    So, I need humor. I thirst for it. Someone today suggested books by Dave Barry and David Sedaris. I may have to resort to humorous books. And there's Carl Hiassen, too. Wacky Floridians seem to be in constant supply in Barry's and Hiassen's books. Just what I need.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No this is not the book to be reading now, Kathy. If I were you and I wanted amusement and chuckles and the occasional laugh out loud moment, I'd try Jeffrey Cohen for a whole slew of funny mysteries. He also writes under the name of E.J. Copperman. I'd also try Parnell Hall's Stanley Hastings books. Mysteries with laughter are unbeatable combo. And for more civilized stuff, I'd try the books of English author Angela Thirkell. I'm currently reading as many of her books as I can find online and loving them to death. VERY dry wit mixed with laugh out loud moments. English wit, to me, is often hilarious. The books mostly take place before and during WWII. She is an absolutely WONDERFUL observer of human frailty. She is a snob though, writing from the point of view of high social standing, but that doesn't bother me in the least. I'd also try the Mapp and Lucia books by E.F. Benson. HILARIOUS. Also English, but wackier than Thirkell. Last but not least, I'd try the Robin Hudson books by Sparkle Hayter (yes, that's her real name) - there aren't that many but what there are, are choice. Also HILARIOUS in a totally American way. The kind of books which you have to be careful reading in public, because people will stare if you being howling. Ha. Also, I believe, the main character lives in or near Greenwich Village.
      Check these out, Kathy - see what you think. Let me know.

      Delete
  8. Years ago I did read a book by Parnell Hall, the first in the series probably. And I did read a book by Sparkle Hayter set in the Chelsea Hotel near my residence.
    Haven't tried Thirkell, but I think the social snobbery would irk me.
    I could try the E.F. Benson books.
    But I think I will try the Barry and Sedaris books, or one by each. And one more of Hiassen's. Amd there's always going back to the West 35th Street brownstone to dine with Nero, Archie and Fritz. Always fun.

    And I do like British wit. My father was from an Irish-English family and he had dry wit, was often cracking jokes or one-liners, and he loved humor. I'd hear him late at night laughing over a book he was reading. And he introduced me to the Goodwin/Wolfe gang.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, whatever you decide to read, I hope you'll find some relief from the day -to-day of political chicanery and the repellent individuals now running our country.

      Delete
  9. You might not like to hear this, but I only read about half a dozen of Innes' mystery novels and have been criminally neglecting him for many years now. Something I should rectify in the near future, because I have roughly twenty of his books on my never decreasing TBR-pile.

    In my defense, I absolutely loved Lament for a Maker and remember thinking Death at the President's Lodging was one of the strongest debuts from the Golden Age.

    I noticed you were missing from my blog-roll, but you're added now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Half a dozen is better than nothing, TomCat. :) LAMENT FOR A MAKER is not one of my favorites, but I know I'm in the minority there. I'm more fond of Innes' flights of fancy books. Ha. And thanks for adding me to your blog-roll.

      Delete
  10. I hope you keep reviewing books by Michael Innes, to remind me that I must read some of his books. I did read many of them when I was younger, and liked them.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello Yvette, now I have to say that I have never read MI but what made me want to post a comment was the book cover because it took me right back to my school days, playing marbles. A lot of fun (if one was winning) and a lot of angst (if one was not winning). I still have my marbles (!!) in the bag that my grandmother made me with its green drawstring. You have given me a very nice memory. Bye for now, Kirk.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We aim to please around here, Kirk. Comments - no matter the reason - are always welcomed. Thanks for dropping by.

      Delete
  12. I thought I'd responded to this before, but maybe I didn't. Anyway, I just bought this book and after reading your review, it moves to the top of the TBR pile.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you enjoy it, Joan. It's an odd book, but that's what I like about it.

      Delete
  13. Yvette, if you're such a big fan of Michael Innes, then it's about time I picked up at least one of his paperbacks and read it. I admit passing up fairly large quantities of his books in secondhand book exhibitions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh my goodness - DO NOT PASS THEM UP!!! Not all his books are great, of course, but MOST OF THEM ARE WONDERFUL. He is one of my very favorite of the Golden Age British writers. He is unique - not one else writes like him or thinks like him or plots like him. He takes getting used to, yes, but once you're hooked on his style, you'll want to read everything. Of that I'm sure. If you see THE CASE OF THE JOURNEYING BOY or OPERATION PAX or SHEIKS AND ADDERS or THE SECRET VANGUARD or FROM LONDON FAR or HARE SITTING UP or THE MAN FROM THE SEA or THE OPEN HOUSE or SILENCE OBSERVED or DEATH ON A QUIET DAY or THE CRABTREE AFFAIR - grab them. Or for that matter, any other Innes. Tastes vary and you may like some others I'm just lukewarm about. Happy reading!

      Delete
    2. I will, Yvette. Thanks for the recommendations. This makes it easy for me.

      Delete
  14. Yvette,

    I finally received a copy of Michael Innes' HAMLET, REVENGE! from the library. I had to go through InterLibraryLoan to get it. It was rather surprising to find that the book had come from the Juneau Library!

    I guess that explains why it took over three weeks to arrive. Those dog sled teams don't do too well, I guess, in the desert heat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! Too bad the dogs can't deliver the book to your door. :) I usually just buy them from Abe Books since most Innes books are available for about 3.50 and free shipping. I have a nice stack of them. But then, I reread them all the time, so it works better for me.

      Delete

Your comment will appear after I take a look.